What to Expect When You’re Expecting… And Gay

Source: Getty Images

Source: Getty Images


Originally published on Mommy Man and cross-posted here with their permission.

So you’re going to be a gay parent? Congratulations!

No doubt you’ve been through a lot to get to this point, whether you’ve traveled the path of adoption, IVF, artificial insemination, surrogacy, fostering, or whatever. Now, you have a lot to do to get ready.

Don’t worry. This isn’t going to be one of those typical posts that tells you to stock up on diapers and learn CPR. Most gay parents are overachievers on that front, I’d guess, since we’ve been planning our families for so long. I know I couldn’t wait to sign up for baby classes.

I wanted to write this post specifically for you, though, the expectant gay parent, because there’s a whole lot of important parenting stuff they’re not going to cover in those baby classes that applies directly to you.

There are some special things you’re going to experience because you have a non-traditional family, and I’ve encountered them, so I wanted to give you my tips on how to deal with them.

1. Your Kids Will Need Perspective

No matter where you live, it’s very likely that your kids will grow up feeling at least slightly out of the mainstream. They’ll see that most families have a mom and dad, and that their family is different.

In my opinion, the best way to handle this is to embrace it.

Celebrate who you are from day one. Always talk about what makes your family special, and make sure you do it in positive terms.

There are some great kids’ books about LGBT-parented families. (I call the books about gay dads “Papa-ganda.”) We love to read The Family Book by Todd Parr, and when we get to the page that says “Some families have two moms or two dads,” I ask the kids “Who has two dads?” And they cheer, “Me!!!”

When they meet other kids, they probably feel that their friends are the ones who are missing out on something special by not having a family like ours.

Yes, my kids are still young (3-1/2 as of right now), so they haven’t asked a ton of uncomfortable questions, and the Mommy issue hasn’t come up too much.

But when that time comes (and I know it will), I’ll be able to talk about our family structure as something wonderful that makes us who we are, because that’s what I’ve been saying all along.

Moms are great, too, but if we had one of those, we wouldn’t have two dads, and we wouldn’t be us.

2. You’ll Constantly Be Outing Yourself

Unless you’re always walking around in your rainbow-striped Pride t-shirt (and good for you if you are), you’re probably passing for straight most of the time, whether you mean to or not.

As a childless person, this is not a big deal. You’re going to the supermarket to pick up a loaf of bread, not to discuss your private life with strangers, right?

Well, once you have kids, people will be even more likely to assume you’re straight. A baby practically announces to the world, “I had intercourse with someone of the opposite sex!”

I can’t tell you how many times a stranger (usually a woman, presumably a mom herself) has seen me pushing my kids in the double stroller through the aisles of Target or changing a diaper in a family restroom and exclaimed, “Your wife sure is lucky!” (Side note: Many straight women apparently have terrible husbands.)

Even when my whole family is out together — me, the kids, and my very obviously male partner — people find ways to force us into their preconceived notions of family structure.

Then, the typical comment we get is “I guess it’s Mom’s day off!”

The assumption here is that my boyfriend and I are platonic buddies whose wives are off on a spa date or something. Hey, I take the spa dates in my family, thank you very much.

Your natural inclination in these situations might be to play along, not out of any kind of self-loathing but just for social expediency.

From most people, these comments are the equivalent of “Hey, nice weather we’re having!” All they’re looking for is for me to respond “Yup!” or “Hey, it’s only fair. Mom works hard, right?”

But whenever I’m tempted to do that, I’ll remember two very good reasons I can’t: my kids.

They love their dads very much, and I’ve been telling them constantly what an amazing and incredibly special family we have. What message would I be sending to them if I suddenly pretended our family was just like everyone else’s? That we need to lie about who we are? That they should lie? That I’m ashamed of being gay? That the opinion of some stranger in a supermarket is more important than the respect of my own children?

So I say it. Regardless of what the situation seems to call for, I out us. “There is no mom. There are two dads in our family” or “I don’t have a wife. I have a partner. A man.”

Then I brace myself, because my real fear is that this person will turn out to be a member of the Westboro Baptist Church or the Boy Scouts senior leadership, and they’ll go all psycho fire and brimstone on me in front of the kids.

Thankfully, that hasn’t happened yet.

Sure, some people are taken aback, because like I said, all they wanted was polite chit-chat, and now they feel forced to say… well, something.

Usually, what they say is “I’m sorry; I shouldn’t have assumed” because they’re embarrassed. In that case, I just smile, because that person is probably very nice and will never make that mistake again.

Remember, your kids come before strangers.

Don’t worry about what some lady at the supermarket thinks. And if you’re in a hurry to get someone to the potty or to pick Other Daddy up at the train station, just correct the lady at the Stop-n-Shop and keep on moving. She’ll figure it out eventually.

Oh, and be prepared to do this with little kids, too.

We sometimes get the question “Where’s their Mommy?” and have to reply “They don’t have one. They have two dads.” It usually ends there – for us, at least. If the questions get any trickier, we can always fall back on “Go ask your parents.”

Not my kids, not my problem.

3. You Will Now Be an Activist for Non-traditional Families

As a childless LGBTQ+ person, it’s entirely possible to live your life in a supportive bubble.

Move to San Francisco or LA. Work for GLAAD. Join a gay softball league. Surround yourself with people who know you and accept you. I’d guess many of us spent the years after coming out doing just that.

Well, if you’re going to have kids, you’re going to have to venture outside your gay-friendly bubble. Constantly.

Your kids will be going to school and playing Little League primarily with kids from mom-and-dad-headed families, and you’ll be interacting with people who won’t always be 100% on board with the whole gay thing.

Even going to IHOP on Family Night can feel like you’re Making a Statement, because some people will figure out immediately exactly what your family is all about.

Hi, welcome to the cause.

What’s that? You’re not a political person? Well, good. Because this isn’t about politics. It’s about your family. And being a good parent means doing what’s best for your kids. You want them to grow up in a better world than you did? Great, then get ready to fight for them.

The good news is that most of the time, you can do this by pushing back gently.

When I filled out my kids’ preschool applications last year, the forms had spaces for “Mother’s Name” and “Father’s Name.” I could’ve just written our names in those spaces. I guess I also could’ve called up and complained or raised a stink. Instead, I simply crossed out “Mother” and wrote “Father #2,″ then submitted the forms as normal.

Why assume that the school was homophobic? It was far more likely that they just hadn’t had any gay parents there before (or any who cared about the forms), so the forms had never been an issue.

You know what? When I filled out their applications the next year, the forms had been updated. There were now two lines labeled “Parent Name.” A subtle change other parents are unlikely to notice, but that meant a lot to me. Best of all, I didn’t have to be someone’s pain in the neck to accomplish it.

But you can’t be silent.

You don’t want your kids to get to school and have the teacher asking them about their “Mommy” or “Daddy” (or whichever parent your family doesn’t include). You never know when a clueless teacher might insist, “Oh no, you have to have a Mommy. Everyone does!” So don’t make your kids do the hard work.

To be honest, though, once you get past your initial anxiety, being an activist is kind of fun.

It can be very empowering to apply for a family membership at the children’s museum, to hand a tourist my iPhone and say “Excuse me, can you take a picture of my family?” or to call in an order to the pharmacist and then add “But I’m going to have her other dad pick it up.”

4. People Will Generally Be Very Nice to You (At Least to Your Face, and That’s All That Matters)

Before I had kids, I assumed I’d meet a lot of resistance from the anti-gay crowd as a dad.

I worried that preschools might turn us away, that other parents would refuse to set up play dates with my kids, that we’d get sneered at or harangued in public.

What can I say? I was stung pretty hard when Prop 8 passed, and I took it very personally. I may even have had a tiny bit of a chip on my shoulder.

But here’s the good news. While I’m sure some of that ugly homophobia is out there, I have yet to face it head-on.

I wrote a piece a while back called “The 5 People You Meet as a Gay Dad” wherein I discussed the reactions I’ve received from people who’ve met my family. And I admitted at the end that the worst thing I’ve dealt with is polite discomfort.

That piece generated a ton of comments, and almost all the other LGBTQ+ parents who wrote in had similar experiences. Even those who lived in much more conservative areas had been pleasantly surprised at the support they’d received.

So you can feel good about your decision to have a family in this world at this time.

I’m constantly touched and encouraged by how accepting and friendly most people are towards us.

They want to learn our story, or to tell me about other gay parents they know. I constantly hear things like “My sister and her wife are trying to have a baby. I’m so excited for them!”

Sometimes they treat us like celebrities, like the nurse when my son was in the hospital. She told us she’d always wanted to meet gay dads, and she jogged around the kid’s hospital bed to give us hugs.

So my ultimate advice is the same thing you probably figured out when you first started coming out: Be yourself and be proud.

Assume the best of people, and very often, that’s what you’ll get.

Now go read those other parenting books and learn about feeding, diapering, swaddling, bathing, and all that.

Being a parent, gay or straight, is the most amazing, rewarding, and totally freaking difficult thing you’ll ever do.

You’ve got a lot to learn.


Want to discuss this further? Login to our online forum and start a post! If you’re not already registered as a forum user, please register first here.

Jerry Mahoney lives with his boyfriend, Drew, and theirr twins Bennett and Sutton, who were born in August 2009. He is currently a stay-home dad raising his kids full-time, but while they’re sleeping, he’s working on a memoir about his family’s whole crazy story, tentatively titled Where Do Gaybies Come From? Follow him on Twitter @WhyJerryWhy.